The New York Times reports that
an obscure paragraph in the recent “fiscal cliff” bill extends a
delay in implementation of Medicare price controls on Sensipar, a
drug used by kidney dialysis patients, for two years. The drug is
manufactured by Amgen. The delay will cost Medicare—and ultimately
taxpayers—$500 million. The section of the bill (Section 762) is
not tranparent and does not mention Amgen by name. It's one of many
examples of pork that are buried in a bill that was supposed to
reduce the deficit.
Here are the details. Currently,
Medicare pays for dialysis drugs individually. They determined that
this created an incentive to overprescribe medication that was
useless and possibly harmful. The change, now postponed, was that
Medicare would pay a single, bundled rate for dialysis treatment. That was a threat to Amgen's profits.
According to the Times, this
decision was made by Senator Max Baucus (D-MT), chair of the Senate
Finance Committee, and Senator Orrin Hatch (R-UT), the ranking
Republican on the committee. It was subsequently approved by Senate
Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) and Vice President Joe Biden,
who negotiated the “fiscal cliff” agreement. Amgen has made over
$5 million in political contributions since 2007, including $67,750
to Senator Baucus, $59,000 to Senator Hatch, $73,000 to Senator
McConnell, and $141,000 to President Obama's two presidential
campaigns.
Sen. Mitch McConnell (or possibly a turtle) |
The Times quotes aides to
Senators Baucus and Hatch and an Amgen spokesperson as saying that
the delay was justified because it would “give Medicare and health
care providers the time they need to accommodate complicated changes
in federal reimbursement for kidney care.” The price restraints
were originally scheduled to begin in 2012. Congress granted Amgen a
two year delay until 2014. The “fiscal cliff” bill extends that
delay until 2016. How much time do they need?
An aide to Senator Baucus added
that, “What is the best policy for Montanans and people across the
country is at the heart of every decision Chairman Baucus makes.”
But none of the people contacted attempted to justify the
decision on medical grounds.
Amgen is the world's largest biotech
corporation, with $15.6 billion in revenue in 2011. It has 74 lobbyists in Washington, including former chiefs of staff of both
Senators Baucus and McConnell. Senator Hatch's leading staff member
on health care policy is a former Amgen employee.
On December 19, Amgen pleaded guilty to
illegally marketing Aranesp, an anti-anemia drug, for purposes the
FDA had explicitly not approved. The $762 million settlement was a new record
for a biotech company.
I think incidents like this pose a
serious threat for single-payer advocates. One of the major
arguments against single payer, which resonates strongly with the
general public, is that the federal government can't be trusted to
run a health care system that will provide quality medical care at a
reasonable price. We usually try to counter that argument by
pointing out that all other countries with single-payer systems achieve better health outcomes than we do at lower cost.
However, the United States is not like
other industrialized countries. It's possible that our level of political
corruption is so much higher than other countries as to make us not
comparable to them. If so, it's impossible to predict how single
payer would fare in this country. Of course, despite our corruption,
Medicare is still cheaper than private insurance. However, if Congress ever passes a single payer bill, it is important that it
contain safeguards that insulate the system from corporate and
political interference.
Update (1/31/13)
Update (1/31/13)
The liberal organization Progressives
United has latched onto this
story and is asking people to sign a petition to the CEO of Amgen
asking him to give back the $500 million. (Good luck on that!) The
petition can be found here.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are always welcome.